Thad Forester's official site

GORUCK Challenge Shorts vs. Lululemon Commission Shorts

By


As someone who wears both brands, this article is to share which one is the most versatile. I realize Lululemon and GORUCK don’t always have the same audience. They aren’t always used for the same activities. However, there is some overlap in uses. Plus, if someone didn’t know any better, they may think: “they are both expensive, so they both must be good for what I need.” This couldn’t be further from the truth.

Disclaimer: even though this article is on the shorts, all my comments apply to the GORUCK Challenge Pants and Lululemon Commission Pants (I have them both too).

Note: I did a review on the Challenge Shorts in late 2023, which you can learn more about them in that article and video. This review doesn’t go into as many specifics on the shorts.

*You can also watch my upcoming YouTube review on these shorts soon at my channel below:

Fit and Comfort

The Challenge Shorts have a 10.5″ inseam, which is longer than the Commission Shorts, offered at both 9″ and 10″. The 10.5″ length is noticeable in both appearance and feel compared to my Commission Shorts 10″ inseam.

Water repellant? Fast Drying?

I’m always interested how well my clothing repels water and dries. The pictures below show an experiment I did where I dipped both shorts in water and got completely wet, wrung them out, then hung to dry outside. After 2 hrs 45 mins, the results were: GORUCK were completely dry. Lululemon were very close to dry, but the pockets were still damp.

Additionally, the GORUCK Challenge Shorts bead water off at first whereas the Lululemon don’t have any repelling properties–they immediately get wet. I wrote more about their ability to repel and dry quickly when I rucked 28 miles in May 2024 in the pouring rain. They performed superbly.


Rain soaked Challenge Shorts at mile 19

Stretchy?

GORUCK has what they call 4-way stretch, which allow ample movement for all activities. This is where Lululemon definitely wins. Their Commission Shorts definitely stretch more and feel better b/c they are softer. They are also thicker than the Challenge Shorts (and all GORUCK Shorts and pants). So, if stretchiness is most important to you, then go with Lululemon.

Durability vs. Comfort

One of the most significant differences between GORUCK and Lululemon clothing is the balance between durability and comfort. GORUCK prioritizes ruggedness and the ability to withstand extreme conditions, making their clothing ideal for those who engage in tough physical activities like rucking, hiking, and other training, along with the option to easily blend in “out on the town”. Lululemon, on the other hand, focuses more on comfort and style, with an emphasis on performance in less demanding environments like offices, yoga studios and gyms.

Functionality vs. Aesthetic

GORUCK’s clothing is highly functional, with features designed to enhance performance in challenging conditions. The aesthetic is understated and practical, with a focus on utility. Lululemon, while also functional, places a greater emphasis on aesthetics. Their clothing is designed to look good both during workouts and in everyday settings, appealing to those who value style as much as performance.

GORUCK Challenge Shorts on a 98 degree summer hike.

Conclusion:

I also compared the GORUCK Challenge Short to Prometheus Design Werx Raider Field Shorts in this article and video.

I enjoy comparing the Challenge Shorts, and other GORUCK clothing, to other good brands b/c I wear GORUCK clothing and use their gear almost daily–in fitness, lounging, in the office and church.

Are there any questions you’ve got about the Challenge Shorts, or any other GORUCK clothing or gear? Let me know. You can email me at: thad@patriottothecore.com

Affiliate Note:

I am a GORUCK affiliate, so I get a small percentage commission with each sale if you purchase GORUCK products from my links. This does not cost you any additional money–the prices are the same for buyers. I do this b/c I have a weird obsession with good gear and clothing. I have used GORUCK products since 2015 and have been impressed with their quality and versatility. I don’t do this to make a living, only to help support my habit of buying high-quality items from GORUCK and other American companies.

GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants Review: Are They Worth the Money?

By

Introduction:

Are they worth the money? Yes! Click here if you want to buy.

For my breakdown as to why, read on below and you can watch my video review here too:

The older I’ve gotten, the more I wear comfortable clothes. Bottom line, I want clothing that is versatile–that I can wear to work, exercise in and wear casually around the house or town.

For my needs, there are several options, but I’ve found what I believe are the most versatile pants available – the GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants. They offer a unique blend of functionality, durability, and style.

Here is a deep dive into 6 reasons the 24.7 Simple Pants are the best for men, therefore worth the money:

  1. Durable Construction: GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants are infused with Nylon.  This ToughDry material is made to be fast-drying, abrasion resistant and lightweight, with 2-way stretch.  Renowned for their robust construction, this makes them ideal pants for anyone facing diverse environments. Crafted from high-quality materials, these pants are designed to withstand the rigors of daily wear and tear, ensuring longevity even in challenging conditions. In addition, they come with the Scars Lifetime Guarantee – you break it, they fix it! I’ve put my oldest pair to the test and sent back one time for repair, which was quickly fixed and returned. There is no better lifetime guarantee on the market.

2. Versatility in Design: One of the standout features of GORUCK Simple Pants is their versatile design. There are no logos, extra pockets or anything that even resembles “tactical”. I often find myself in urban settings to rugged terrains to the unplanned pick-up game of basketball or football with my boys. Having pants made for movement and style will not limit you and they seamlessly transition between these environments, offering a practical solution for individuals constantly on the move.

Getting blister work while wearing the GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants for 28 Mile Ruck

I wore the Simple Pants for our annual Mark Forester 28 Mile Ruck in 2021. It was sunny the entire day, with the humidity of north Alabama, and temp in the 80’s (Fahrenheit). I had no issues with sweating or being too hot or restricted. They provided protection so my legs were one less part of my body that could get sun burned since it took us 11 continuous hours.

Simple design with no loud logos on the outside.

3. Comfortable Fit: Comfort is a prerequisite for me, and GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants deliver on this front. The thoughtful design includes a comfortable fit that allows for ease of movement without compromising style. Whether navigating crowded streets, engaging in physical activities or lounging on the couch, these pants provide the flexibility required for diverse tasks.

4. Quick Drying, Moisture Wicking and Water Repellant: GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants are equipped with moisture-wicking properties, ensuring that wearers stay dry and comfortable even in humid or wet climates. Additionally, the quick-drying feature is a game-changer for those caught in unexpected rain or facing the challenge of limited laundry facilities, or just too lazy to do laundry.

Of course, if you’re doing a GORUCK event, these pants are obviously made for them–get wet, muddy, bear crawls, burpees, rucking–you name it–anything. Either these Simple Pants or the Challenge Pants (if you want the side pockets) are go-to’s for GORUCK events.

Water rolling right off in shower.

5. Stylish Aesthetics: While functionality is paramount, GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants do not compromise on style. The clean and minimalist design ensures that wearers can seamlessly blend into diverse cultural settings without sacrificing a polished appearance. This makes these pants a versatile and suitable choice for various active-man contexts. I wear them to the office and they are my go-to for overnight travel. These are called simple for a reason–they don’t have hidden or zippered pockets, only two front and two back.
An additional note: if you prefer skinny pants, these are probably not for you. These are for movement and style. So your calves will not bulge in these b/c they have a straight cut at the bottom.

6. Ease of Care: These pants want to be worn often and even multiple times between washes. And they do not require ironing. Wash in cold water, air dry and wear; allowing for a shorter turnaround time between washing and wearing again. It can’t get any easier, I promise.

Conclusion:

If adaptability, durability, and comfort are crucial to you, GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants are the clear choice. Their robust construction, versatile design, and built to last ToughDry fabric make them the go-to option for those seeking reliable and adaptable clothing. In addition, they fold up (or roll up) to the size of a can of Coke for easy packing and travel.  For those who want tough, comfortable pants, while committed to making a lasting impact, GORUCK 24.7 Simple Pants prove to be an indispensable necessity on your journey.

I’ve been wearing the gray/charcoal Simple Pants for over 3 years, so this is an informed review. I’ve worn the coyote Simple Pants for over 2 years. I ruck with them, travel in them, wear to work, cut my grass, hike and even exercise in them–especially when it’s cold and I need tough pants. These really are the hidden gem in the GORUCK catalog. They will last for years and still look new–mine do.

These pants come in lightweight (about $105) and midweight (about $115). The obvious difference is lightweight is thinner, better for hot temperatures. I have both and use both, but prefer the midweight for colder weather.

Have I missed anything? What questions do you have?

In full disclosure, I have the Lululemon ABC and Commission pants that feel great and that I love. I got these years ago before GORUCK’s Simple Pants existed. The limitation with them is I’d never wear them in the woods or get muddy. They would fray with the first briar stick. Yes, they are stretchy and feel great, but the benefits stop there. And they are cheaper than Lululemon!